Fake Apologies: How to Recognize and How to Respond?

Humans make mistakes, and it is natural to want to apologize when we do. However, not all apologies are created equal, and some can be used as a form of manipulation rather than a genuine expression of remorse.

I'll admit, I used to be terrible at spotting a fake apology. I projected my own sincerity onto others and took their words at face value. That is, until I learned the manipulative tactics used to evoke empathy while dodging responsibility.

In this post, I'll share my personal experiences with fake apologies and offer guidance on how to recognize and respond to them.

What is a Fake Apology?

A fake apology is insincere, vague, or manipulative. These apologies are often used to placate someone without taking responsibility for the harm caused. They may also be used to shift the blame onto the person harmed or minimize the severity of the situation. The purpose of fake apologies is to avoid accountability for the impact of one's actions.

5 Common Tactics Used in Fake Apologies

  1. Blaming the victim - shift the blame onto the person who was harmed. For example, "I'm sorry you got upset," or "I'm sorry if you took it the wrong way." This type of apology does not acknowledge the harm caused and instead puts the responsibility on the victim's reaction.
  2. Making excuses for the behavior that caused harm. For instance, "I'm sorry, but I was really stressed out," or "I didn't mean to hurt you, but I had a lot going on." This type of apology does not take responsibility for the harm caused and instead tries to justify the behavior.
  3. Minimizing the harm caused. For example, "I'm sorry, but it was just a joke," or "It's not that big of a deal, so I don't know why you're upset." This type of apology dismisses the harm caused and does not take it seriously.
  4. Using vague language that does not acknowledge the specific behavior that caused harm. For example, "I'm sorry for everything that happened," or "I'm sorry for any pain I may have caused." This type of apology does not take responsibility for the specific behavior that caused harm and instead makes a general statement.
  5. Focusing on the apologizer's feelings rather than the harm caused. For instance, "I feel terrible about what happened," or "I'm really upset that things turned out this way." While it is important for the apologizer to acknowledge their feelings, this should not take the place of a sincere apology that acknowledges the harm caused and takes responsibility for it.

These tactics aim to avoid accountability for the harm caused. My ex-partner was a master of these tactics, even fooling professionals trained in conflict resolution. This highlights the danger of not recognizing fake apologies – it creates a culture where lies and manipulation thrive.

Responding to Fake Apologies with Strength

When faced with a fake apology, instead of simply reacting, take control of the situation with a response that prioritizes your well-being and sets clear boundaries. Here's how:

  • Express your feelings and validate your experience: "I appreciate the apology, but I still feel hurt by what happened. You [describe specific action/behavior] and it made me feel [describe your emotions]."
  • Request a genuine apology that acknowledges the harm: "A sincere apology would take responsibility for your actions and the impact they had on me. Can you try again?"
  • Set a clear boundary: "Until I receive a genuine apology that addresses my concerns, I'm not comfortable continuing this conversation."

Remember, you are not obligated to accept an apology that feels insincere. It's okay to walk away from the situation if necessary to protect yourself from further manipulation.

What If You're the One Offering Fake Apologies?

A sincere apology is a gift. If you've used manipulative tactics, it's time to take responsibility:

  1. Acknowledge the harm: Be specific about how your actions impacted others.
  2. Apologize sincerely: "I'm truly sorry for..."
  3. Avoid excuses: Focus on your actions and how to do better.
  4. Make amends: Offer explanations, take steps to prevent future harm.
  5. Commit to change: Set goals, seek support if needed.

Remember, apologizing without changing your behavior is just another form of manipulation. Fake apologies erode trust and can lead to serious emotional and mental health consequences. If you're not ready to apologize sincerely and change, be honest about it. It's better for everyone involved.

Trust Your Instincts

If you're on the receiving end of fake apologies, trust your gut. Focus on the person's actions and impact, not just their words. If in doubt, seek professional guidance.

Let's build a culture of genuine communication and accountability, starting with ourselves.

Written by
Jura Glo

With over ten years of experience guiding individuals and couples worldwide, I specialize in supporting those impacted by complex trauma.  

My personal experience navigating cults, institutional betrayal, and manipulative individuals has given me a unique understanding of the psychological and emotional impact of these dynamics.

This translates into my work and writing, where I help my clients identify core issues and co-create solutions within a safe, balanced and supportive environment.

Where to start?

Book a free assessment call to find out if and how I can help you improve your life and relationships

Book a free assessment call
Have you worked with me before? Book a single session